Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter and GIVEAWAY

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

This post was sponsored by OXO.

Thanksgiving is just around the corner. Last year I did a whole month of Thanksgiving recipes. This year, I’m covering the center of the feast – the TURKEY! There is a lot of controversy that surrounds this famed American tradition of turkey roasting. Stuff it? Baste it? Cook on a rack? In a bag? Roast all day at a low temperature or in high heat to sear in the juices? Then there’s wet brining, dry brining, oil or butter, the list goes on.

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

I’m not going to tell you any one method is better than another. If you have a tried and true method of cooking your turkey, I am certainly not going to try to make you change it. What I will do is offer a few tips and tricks of my own that have worked for me. And if you want to share some of yours, please do so by commenting below!

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

OXO provided me and several other bloggers with the ultimate Turkey Day tools AND they are giving you a chance to win a set of your own! Enter to win these innovative OXO tools via the PromoSimple widget below. These tools are essentials for your Thanksgiving Day prep and because they’re OXO you know they will be of the highest quality. Included in the package is:

Poultry Lifter

Twine Dispenser

Angled Baster with Cleaning Brush

2 Cup Fat Separator

Stainless Steel Butter Dish

 Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

Now, back to that bird. For my turkey, I use a good dose of Simon and Garfunkel… Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme. Anyone? Bueller?  Ahem, for reals now, this is the perfect combo of herbs for Thanksgiving. Add in some butter and wine and it’s perfection.

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

These are my tricks to getting a juicy, flavorful turkey with crispy skin:

  • Brining: I don’t bother. It takes too much time and effort (and space in my fridge). That said, if I find a turkey that has already been brined, why not?
  • Fresh or Frozen: I like to buy fresh birds because, well again, time. I don’t want to defrost a frozen bird in my fridge for 4-5 days. I preorder my fresh turkey and pick it up the day before. I let it sit uncovered in the fridge overnight to let the skin dry out and take it out of the fridge 1 hour before cooking.
  • Stuffing: NO. Just no. I’ll take my dressing on the side, thank you. Not only do you need to overcook the turkey to get the stuffing up to a safe temperature, the thought of eating softened sausage and bread out of the cavity of a turkey? – eww.
  • Twine: I tie my turkey legs together with twine. It keeps all the goodies inside the bird and it looks pretty. OXO makes it easy with simple pull & cut twine system.

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

  • Turkey Timers: I never rely on the turkey timer. They are not reliable. I always have a real thermometer and test the temperature of the turkey in 3 places: the breast, the thigh crease and the thigh. Once the turkey registers 165 degrees, I remove it from the oven. This time when I took my turkey out of the oven, the turkey timer popped out 10 minutes later. No good.
  • Rack or Bag: I have cooked turkeys in both a cooking bag and on a rack. The bag has produced some juicy meat but the skin doesn’t crisp. And who can resist a good piece of crispy skin? C’mon, it’s Turkey day. You’re allowed to indulge a little.
  • Temperature: I like to start out at 450 for 30 minutes and then reduce the heat to 350. This allows the fat to melt quickly and help keep the turkey moist.
  • Oil or Butter: Some like oil, some like butter and some use both. I like to use an herb butter under the skin and because I want to really get that herb flavor throughout, I stick with this on the outside too. (TIP: to really infuse your meat with lots of flavor, and keep your breast moist, run your hand in between the breast and skin and stuff it with butter, herbs and whatever else you want.)
  • Basting: Many will tell you not to baste because it reduces the temperature of the oven, blah blah blah. I like to baste. It cools the temperature of the skin down which helps to keep it from burning. This a hotly debated topic and I say to each his own. I love OXO’s angled baster. It makes it easy to get into the crevices of the roasting pan and pull up those juices.

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

What are your turkey dos and don’ts? Successes and failures? Weigh in. And don’t forget to enter to win!

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

I received the above-mentioned set of OXO tools to assist in creating a turkey recipe for #OXOTurkeyDay. I received no other compensation and all opinions are my own.

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

Servings: 14 • Size: approx. 5 ounces • Weight Watcher Points+: 6

Calories: 257 • Fat: 13g • Carbs: 0g • Fiber: 0g • Protein: 32g

Sugars: 0g • Sodium: 167mg • Cholesterol: 117mg

**Nutrition facts are based on a mixture of light and dark meat with skin


  • 1 (14 pound) fresh or defrosted turkey*
  • 1 lemon
  • 1 orange
  • 1 cup salted butter, slightly softened
  • 1 ½ Tablespoons minced parsley
  • 1 ½ Tablespoons minced sage
  • 1 ½ Tablespoons minced rosemary
  • 1 ½ Tablespoons minced thyme
  • 1 small onion
  • 1 head garlic
  • Salt & pepper
  • Small bunch of parsley, sage, rosemary & thyme
  • ½ cup wine
  • ½ cup turkey stock (or chicken if unavailable)


Rest fresh or defrosted turkey uncovered overnight in the refrigerator. Remove from refrigerator 1 hour before cooking.

Preheat oven to 450 degrees.

Zest the lemon and orange. (Set aside fruit.) Mix zest into the butter together with the parsley, sage, rosemary & thyme. Set aside.

Cut the lemon and orange in half, reserving half and cutting the other half into smaller pieces. Quarter the onion and halve the cloves of garlic. Don’t bother removing the skins from either. Liberally salt and pepper the inside cavity of the turkey and stuff it with the lemon and orange pieces, onion, garlic and small bunch of herbs. Tie together the legs with twine. (See photos for my twine tying technique.)

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

Run your hand between the breasts and the skin, being careful not to tear the skin. Stuff it with half the herb butter mixture. Rub the rest of the herb butter on the outside of the breast. Tuck the wings under the bird. Place the turkey on a rack in a roasting pan and into the oven. Bake 30 minutes.

Meanwhile, combine the wine and turkey stock in a large measuring cup. Juice the remaining halves of the orange and lemon into the liquid.

After the 30 minutes has passed, reduce the oven temperature to 350 and baste the turkey with the wine/stock mixture. Baste every 30 minutes until the turkey is done – 2 ½ to 3 hours or until temperature measured at the thigh reaches 165 degrees*.

Remove turkey from the oven and let it rest for 20 minutes before carving.

*Generally, the cooking time is 13 minutes per pound of turkey. Adjust your cooking time as necessary for the size turkey you have.

Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter

2 Responses to “Thanksgiving Turkey with Herb Butter and GIVEAWAY”

Leave a Fab Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Me
Hi! I'm Barbara and yes, I cook! Welcome to my world of mouth-watering delicious food that you don't have to feel guilty about.
More about me →

Recent Recipes

Roasted Crimson Gold Apples with Fennel & Prosciutto
Watermelon Salsa
Mango Strawberry Smoothie
Hawaii - A Farmers' Market Perspective
Minted Strawberry Melon Salad